top of page
Untitled (11 x 8.5 in).png
Untitled (11 x 8.5 in).png

Book reviews are simply a reflection of each reader's individual experience.

IN MY OPINION

Don't Judge a Book by Its Reviewer: Why You Should Trust Your Own Taste

My 'brand' (IMO, In My Opinion) is deeply rooted in the understanding that book reviews are inherently subjective. Why? Because I've spent over 20 years immersed in the world of reviews – books, movies, music, you name it. And let me tell you, some of those critiques have truly made me cringe. It's frustrating to see a work of art, something someone poured their heart and soul into, get torn apart by a reviewer who just didn't connect with it.

We've all heard the saying, "Opinions are like... well, you know," and it couldn't be truer when it comes to reviews. Of course, we need reviews! Sites like Goodreads are invaluable for discovering new works and getting a sense of what others think. But even I'll admit, I sometimes find myself automatically judging a book with a less-than-stellar rating. That's a habit I'm actively trying to break, and I want to help others do the same.

My goal is to encourage readers to look beyond those star ratings and delve deeper into the why behind the reviews. What aspects of the book are people criticizing? Do those criticisms align with your preferences? Remember, a book review is just a snapshot of one reader's experience, not the whole picture. Read the blurb, take a chance, and trust your judgment. You might just discover your next favorite read!

We've all been there. You're browsing online, excited to start a new book, and then you see it – a terrible review that tears apart the very story you were about to read. Suddenly, your enthusiasm dwindles. But hold up! Before you let one person's opinion dictate your reading choices, let's remember a fundamental truth: book reviews are subjective and Just because they didn't click with the story, doesn't mean you won't fall in love in with it.

 

Think about it. What one person finds boring, another might find captivating. Take a book with a plot that unfolds slowly and super complex characters. Some readers might love that kind of depth, while others might find it boring or 'uneventful.' But that doesn't mean the book is automatically good or bad. It just shows how different people connect with stories in their way.

Our individual preferences, past experiences, and even our current mood can all affect how we perceive a book. If you're someone who loves thrillers with tons of action, you might not be into a book that's all about exploring characters' inner thoughts and feelings. And if you're looking for a fun, lighthearted read to escape reality, a book that dives deep into serious social issues might not be your cup of tea.

And let's talk about those star ratings. These days, with sites like Goodreads, Amazon, and even just scrolling through your social media, it's super easy to slap a rating on a book and call it a day. But let's be real, can we sum up everything we feel about a book with just a few stars? What one person thinks is a "meh" three-star read might be someone else's absolute favorite. We see those shiny gold stars and think, "Oh, this must be amazing!" But those stars are just telling you what one person thought, not some universal truth about the book.

The problem is, that these ratings have real-world consequences. Authors, especially those just starting out, rely on positive reviews to gain visibility and attract readers. A string of low ratings can unfairly impact a book's success, potentially discouraging readers from giving it a chance.

Let's not forget the sheer amount of work that goes into writing a book. Authors pour their hearts and souls into their craft, often spending years developing characters, weaving plots, and painstakingly revising their work. They deserve to be recognized for that effort, even if their book isn't everyone's cup of tea. As much as I love to read, I could never write my own book, therefore, IMO, an author deserves so much credit for the time they put into their work. 

Personally, I could never bring myself to give a book a one-star rating. Even if I didn't connect with a story, I can still appreciate the time and dedication that went into creating it. When leaving a review, it's important to be mindful and constructive. Offer specific examples of what worked and what didn't, and remember that your opinion is just one among many.

The beauty of reading lies in its personal nature. It's about the unique connection formed between the reader and the story. So, why let someone else's opinion overshadow your own potential enjoyment?

Of course, reviews can be helpful in discovering new books or getting a general sense of a story. But they shouldn't be the ultimate deciding factor. Trust your gut, explore genres that intrigue you, and form your own opinions. After all, the most important critic is the one holding the book.

Ah, the coveted five-star review! It's the holy grail for readers and authors alike. But what does it really take for a book to earn that perfect rating?

Here's IMO-

  • A Page-Turner: This one's a no-brainer. A five-star book needs a plot that grabs you from the first page (or first couple of chapters) and keeps you hooked until the very end, like can’t put the book down, stay up all night kind of book. No matter the genre—whether it's a thriller that keeps you on the edge of your seat, a literary fiction that makes you think, or a romance that sweeps you off your feet—a truly great story needs to be engaging and stay with you long after you've turned the final page.

  • Well-Developed Characters: I want to feel invested in the characters, to understand their motivations, and root for them (or against them!). Whether they're relatable or completely outlandish, the characters need to feel real and jump off the page.
     

  • Strong Writing: The author's writing style plays a huge role. Evocative language, vivid imagery, and a distinct voice can elevate a good story to a great one.
     

  • Hits You Right In The Feels: For me, a five-star read needs to make me feel something. And trust me, I'm a crier, so if a book can wring tears out of me, it's practically guaranteed those five stars. But it's not just about the waterworks. Whether it makes me laugh, sends my mind spinning with new feels, or just leaves lingering thoughts that I can't shake off, that kind of deep connection is what earns a book top marks in my book.

 

  • A Satisfying Conclusion: The ending is crucial. It doesn't necessarily have to be happy, but it needs to feel earned and provide a sense of closure.
     

Of course, these are just my opinions, not universal truths. What makes a five-star read is subjective and varies from person to person. But these are the elements that usually come together to create a truly unforgettable reading experience for me.

We have designed somewhat of a "template" for our book reviews on this site. If you see ​

this means we have read and completed a review on that book. They will also be listed under 

our blog "IMO Book Lovers Review".

Please note-since this site is new-this will take time to get our reviews updated.

 

If you would like to leave your book review please let us know!

 

Now, tell me, what's a book you loved that everyone else seemed to hate? Let's celebrate the power of individual taste!

Book Review Request

Contact/Comments

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page